About the Blog

My blog post are of varied topics ranging from personal experiences, travel, wild life photographs, interesting news, of happenings around the world that catches my fancy. In other words i write about anything when i am in a mood to write

Saturday, March 3, 2012

Dangerous Precedent

Tamilnadu is starting the profiling of migrant labor working in Chennai , an aftermath of the encounter killing of 5 suspected bank robbers who were from the northern states of India. This is totally against the democratic rights of each and every individual of  India who are allowed to take employment in any part of India without any harassment. The police spokesman states that the workers would not be harassed however the ground reality is totally different. Now coming to the profiling part i really do not know how does the profiling of migrant workers would weed out the anti social element since the details sought are only the records of the person. It would only create a data base of the workers being employed in Chennai or Tamilnadu and nothing more than that. Further as per the reports in the papers it is clear that most crime are not done by people coming here from the other states and  the prejudice shown by the Tamilnadu police is unfounded. If at all the profiling has to be done then each and every resident of the state needs to be a subject of this.... equality to one and all Indians.

Most of the criminals today are quite educated and it is wrong to preconceive that only unskilled or uneducated persons take to crime. The recent bank heists suspects were educated and well to do and yet chose to increase their wealth criminally and how does the Tamilnadu police monitor so many lakhs of people coming to Chennai for working in various companies or for studying. There is a definite flaw in thoughts of enumeration/profiling and if it is not scrapped then they are setting up an dangerous precedent for the other states to cite or follow similar procedures affecting scores of Tamilians working out the state.

I reproduce below the views of Times of India for fueling your thoughts on this issue

The decision to profile migrant labor goes against the spirit of social integration as enshrined in the Constitution. The stated objective of crime prevention rests on the presumption that migrants are responsible for rising levels of crime though present data may not support such a claim. Activists have raised concerns that the process could instill suspicion among locals and sow seeds of disharmony. The state should give up the exercise and focus on improving policing instead.


 




Your views and comments on the course of action taken by Tamilnadu Police please. !!

10 comments:

  1. Well expressed sir !
    This will spoil our integrity and already i dont find integrity in us :(
    sad state of India

    ReplyDelete
  2. Yes Deepak the very fabric of social/ national integration is being shredded. Even the universities have started the same exercise and the house owners also have been asked to reveal tenant particulars now. Becoming a police state and in days to come i will not be surprised if we need to approvals similar to visa to go out of the state to different part of India. Sad state of affairs indeed !!!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Whatever the polic esay we have to believe!
    What a shame! How come we still blame Shiv sena then?

    As you said most of the crimes have upper echelons. If only the police was as alert for all the crimes/ and profiling them too!
    ( it will be ramrajya).

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Absolutely true Vetrimagal...a shame indeed !!!

      Delete
  4. I think this kind of profiling must be linked to a larger plan of using the collected data properly! If they just collect data then it is just that. I am not personally against this move considering that our country is becoming infested with criminals - case in point the latest news abt SRM college engineering students beating up their cook and threatening others with guns! I mean whats the need for students to have guns...

    What the government should refrain from is simply collecting data for teh sake of it (just to shut up the public) and allow the police officers to harass the public (for some petty bribes)! And yes this should be done all over teh country and not just 1 state! There needs to be a central database - that way its more easy to track criminal jerks!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. True Shweta these needs to be done through out India and i do not see this being done for a very very long time to come... you know the reasons why!!!!

      Delete
  5. Well put down! Love the way you've tackled the issue!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you Rohit for your comments...This is the sorry state of affairs in India and the educated lot need to bring about a change.

      Delete
  6. This is really bad and absurd too. You are right, this kind of profiling does give rise to discrimination.

    http://rachnaparmar.com

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you for comments Rachna and you are correct in summarizing it.

      Delete